Well -- American Idol contestants performed some of the most popular downloaded songs on iTunes.
First, I have to comment about the performing order. I'm not sure how they select the order of contestants to perform, but obviously those who go later in the competition seem to have an advantage.
Second, Simon -- I love you and think you're right most of the time, but WHAT IS UP WITH YOUR HAIR? Holy cow... it looks SO bad! ("Not to be rude." haha). It was kind of a flat top tonight but parted down the middle. It reminded me of the parting of the Red Sea from the 10 Commandments. :)
Here are my comments about tonight's American Idol (I would love to hear your opinions as well):
Anoop Desai: Usher "Caught Up". Anoop is a good singer. I didn't like the performance nor the song choice for him, and he seemed like he was trying to be intense. It didn't come across well for me. Simon's comment that it was "a complete and utter mess" I thought was a bit harsh, but I did agree that it didn't really work for him. I predict he will be in the bottom 3 this week.
Megan Joy: Bob Marley "Turn Your Lights Down Low". I actually liked Megan during the auditions and I know some who love her. I think she's a darling girl, but she is beginning to feel stagnant and I can't wait for her performances to be over. She could have potential and if she could really find her niche and make everything her own, she would do better. I did not like her song choice this week at all. It felt really flat. Simon said, "boring, indulgent monotonous." Randy "like watching paint dry." I do think if her response had been humble and funny rather than a flippant comment she may have a chance to stay, but as it is, unless someone else really messes up, I think she's at risk for going home. I think she'll be in the bottom 3 for sure.
Danny Gokey: Rascal Flatts "What Hurts the Most". I love him. Have I said before that I love him? (Big grin). He is SO REAL. That is what I love the most. I actually got goosebumps during his performance. The crowd seemed to feel it too and Cara nailed it when she commented "you moved everyone in this room emotionally." Even Simon loved him "It was your best performance of the season." This is one I'll for sure buy.
Allison Iraheta: No Doubt "Don't Speak". So I didn't like this one at all. It felt like she was yelling the song and even Simon commented similarly. She really can sing and I think she's safe this week, but I didn't think there was any real connection.
Scott MacIntyre: Billy Joel "Just the Way You Are." I really like Billy Joel and this song, but it was kind of painful to listen tonight. I actually like Scott as a person (not that I know him, but I like what he seems to be). However, I have a hard time listening to him sing - it feels to me like the same tone and feeling through every single song - no dynamics and the tone is not my favorite. BUT... it's personal taste here, because he obviously can sing. Just not someone that I would ever pay to hear sing. Since he was in the bottom 3 last week, I actually think he could go home this week, and possibly end up keeping Megan in the competition.
Matt Giraud: The Fray "You Found Me". I found Matt's performance down in the audience surrounded by fans a bit strange. I didn't really like the song that much, but he did a good job. I just didn't think it showcased him very much. Simon "I didn't get it at all. Very uptight." I actually did agree with Simon in the fact that he seemed to not really be himself - more like trying to be someone else. I wonder if since Matt was in the bottom three last week, if his fans will band together to keep him here another week. He really is talented, but I do wonder if he has found a fan base that will be loyal enough to keep him around.
Lil Rounds: Celine Dion "I Surrender". When Lil started to sing, I was worried. I thought it was going to be a mess. But she actually did a really good job. I was impressed. My concern for her is that she may not have enough of a "Lil Rounds" flavor in everything she does - she kind of becomes what she is singing, rather than taking the song and making it "Lil". She really can sing though! "Your personality is being sucked out of you" (Simon). Lil's daughter is darling - and hugging Randy was priceless. That actually may end up keeping Lil around (haha).
Adam Lambert: Wild Cherries "Play that Funky Music". I actually love this song, but "ick" is all I can say. Obviously Adam made it completely his style (felt like something you might see Mick Jagger or even Twisted Sister or some hard rock group doing, but again, I did not like it at all. His performance felt like he was just screaming it - he can hit crazy notes. I am sure others will love it - but I absolutely hated it! Funny that Paula mentioned Mick Jagger and Stephen Tyler. He is so cute and I really want to like him, but I just can't. Obviously he is going to be wildly popular for a long time and have a fantastic career, but ugh. (Actually I felt the same way about Chris Doughtry when he was on American Idol - I hated his vibrato - but I love him now and love the Doughtry album. So there may be a chance that Adam will grow on me, but for now, I don't think so.)
Kris Allen: "Ain't No Sunshine". Kris is growing on me. I think he always seems to be himself and brings his own style to whatever he does. The first week I thought he didn't stand out enough, but he's doing great. I loved his performance. I can easily see him having a great career. Simon "Your best performance so far."
My predictions for the bottom three tomorrow: Anoop, Megan and Scott. But as for who will go home - it's really a toss up for me. What do you think???
Labels: Adam Lambert, Allison Iraheta, American Idol, Anoop Desai, Contestants, Danny Gokey, Kris Allen, Lil Rounds, Matt Giraud, Megan Joy, Scott MacIntyre, TV